Amazons Huge Expenditure on the Bessemer Anti-Union Campaign: Amazon is paying a small fortune for its anti-union consultants. You need to emphasize to employees from the beginning that a third party is never necessary when there is a problem. Since Littler was founded in San Francisco in 1942, union avoidance has been a major area of its expertise. Edge Beginning in the 1950s, an industry of consultants and law firms started advising companies on how to avoid unionization campaigns. According to a filing with the Department of Labor, Amazon engaged the services of LIS starting January 3, 2021, for the purpose of "conducting meetings with employees in the voting bargaining unit to discuss the realities of signing authorization cards and voting in the upcoming . Civil rights leaders, ministers at black churches, and leaders of historically black colleges criticized Nissan for running one of the nastiest anti-union campaigns in modern American history. The United Auto Workers (UAW) and the global union federation IndustriALL subsequently filed a complaint accusing Nissan of violating the OECD Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises. When addressed early, organizing is avoidable. In 2019, Kumho workers voted for the steelworkers, after the NLRB ordered a rerun election, and after numerous company efforts to delay, the labor board finally certified their victory in 2021. . Advised by its U.S. union avoidance lawyers, Nissan insisted that the U.S. NCP should not broker an agreement that would place the company in a position of . She's fourth generation union, raised in an activist-union household. provided for informational purposes only and should not be considered legal These employee relations assessments are almost always appreciated by the employees, and the insights derived from these conversations provide management with a valuable opportunity to address areas of concern in a proactive manner. Advertisement. 616-742-3999, F Univar USA. This is why the Protecting the Right to Organize (PRO) Act, which passed the House of Representatives earlier this month, is desperately needed to safeguard workers choice. IKEA, for example, turned to Ogletree Deakins, one of the largest law firms that specialize in so-called union avoidance activities, to help it crush unionization efforts in Stoughton, Massachusetts, in 2016. In 2019, Google hired IRI Consultants, a union avoidance firm, "amid a wave of unprecedented worker organizing at the company," as Vice's Motherboard put it in January 2021, while reporting on leaked files from IRI that provided a disturbing picture of how far Google may have strayed in its . When determining the appropriate mix of tools to assess risk, we recommend organizations consider the following: 1. Union-Free Strategies and Considerations In the 'New Normal', Federal Court Orders Starbucks to Re-Hire Terminated Union Supporters, The Price for Refusing to Bargain May Soon be Going Up for Employers, Say It Aint So (Trader) Joes: Grocery Chain Workers File Union Petition, NLRB General Counsel Takes Aim at Employer Free Speech, Supreme Court Favors Employer Property Rights Over Union Access To Employees, Goodbye NY: No Union For Uber DriversFor Now, $250,000 in Grants Awarded to Five Nonprofit Organizations, Illinois Employers on Notice: BIPA Claims Accrue With Each Scan or Transmission, Court Says. We are, at times, more than lawyers, we are advisers bringing new ideas to light. to attack global union federations by making their financial records publicly available. It is a form of union avoidance that involves tactics such as intimidation, misinformation, and legal challenges to limit or . Terms of Use & Disclaimer. There seems little doubt that when the campaign at Bessemer is finally over, Amazon will have paid millions of dollars to its law firm and its union avoidance consultants. It's not only Morgan Lewis: Amazon has links to other leading union avoidance firms and experts: Amazon has connections with several other leading anti-union law firms. . Littler attorneys have argued that, under international law, employers not only have a right, but also have an obligation to oppose unions: ILO jurisprudence requires them to speak out against unionization, otherwise workers will be denied access to information they need to make an informed choice: [I]t may be a violation of international law for employers to be limited in their right to freedom of expression and opinion . Although we excel in union avoidance and elections, a hallmark of Littler's practice remains the ability to prevent workplace issues from ending up in court or administrative tribunals, sparing our clients time-consuming and costly headaches. The Starbucks Workers United union campaign has now won over 164 National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) elections, and over 300 stores have petitioned for NLRB elections. In 2018, Littler employed over 1000 attorneys in the United . The union avoidance industry continued to grow, and LRA served as a breeding ground for several future superstars of the union-free movement. Failure to recognize early warning signs of union activity can result in having to engage in a costly and disruptive union campaign, which can create deep and long-lasting divisions within the workforce, not to mention the negative consequences should the union prevail (e.g., increased costs, restrictive work rules, work stoppages, etc.). [iv] https://www.amazon.com/Union-Hypocrisy-Organized-Standard-Business/dp/1478275162(https://www.amazon.com/Union-Hypocrisy-Organized-Standard-Business/dp/1478275162), (https://tunein.com/podcasts/Conservative-Talk/The-Brenner-Brief-w-Sara-Marie-Brenner-p514156/) (https://www.rwplabor.com/consultant-bios/rebecca-smith/). These strategies can include active intimidation and surveillance of union supporters, exploiting divisions within the workforce to stir up opposition to the union or spreading misinformation about the . Like Littler, it has expanded by opening its own overseas offices, rather than engaging in alliances with other management law firms. Rebecca Smith: A second consultant working with Russ Brown at Amazon, Rebecca Smith, claims to have worked for unions 20 years, 16 years with the Teamsters, including as Executive Director of Training for Southern Nevada. The union campaign among 2200 workers at Fuyao Glass, during which the UAW complained that workers had faced a a barrage of anti-labor tactics and intimidation, was the subject of the academy-award winning documentary, American Factory, in which the company president talked about firing union supporters. The NLRB found that the company had committed numerous and egregious unfair labor practices during its anti-union campaign in a 2017 NLRB election. Seaton is a well-known union-avoidance consultant, otherwise known as a "persuader" or, more accurately, a union buster. By agreeing to remain silent, an employer effectively may deny workers information, opinions and ideas they have a right to receive . necessary.17. January 18, 2023. The relationship between union membership and job satisfaction is still disputed vigorously among scholars. Google's Union-Busting Methods Revealed - THE TOP 25 MOST CENSORED STORIES OF 2020-2021. According to Pitt's financial disclosure reports, the Office of University . Don't forget to like us! Take our Union Vulnerability Assessment Quiz and find out if your company is susceptible to union organizing. The Great Railroad Strike of 1877 in . The "Big Four" Union Avoidance Law Firms Go Global. Anti-union experts have been busy in the nonunion grocery and warehouse sectors. According to Motherboard, leaked polling spreadsheets from one of the most prominent union avoidance firm, IRI Consultants, show how anti-union consultants profile and essentially characterize . This month, we found out that Amazon is using a second anti-union consultant firm which is an unusual step, even for an anti-union firm like Amazon: California-based Labor Information Services. After leaving the Teamsters reportedly fired for gross incompetence Smith started working as a anti-union consultant. Smith has an extensive background in conservative political circles: she has published an anti-union book, Union Hypocrisy, which is written in the nature of [right-wing] political authors Laura Ingraham and Michelle Malkin and she has been a Contributor to the ultra-conservative Brenner Brief podcast. While critical of the shred it! campaign, the CFA defended employers right of free expressionthe first time, according to Littler attorneys, that it had made such a statement.19. Consultants . Chaired by Jackson Lewis attorneys and headquartered in Brussels, L&E Global now has over twenty partner law firms and offers services in over 25 jurisdictions spanning six continents, including the European Union, Australia, Brazil, India, and China. Unions have filed OECD complaints during several global organizing campaigns, including those at Nissan, T-Mobile, DHL, and Ikea. 1. Our site is These firms have perfected union avoidance techniques that make it extraordinarily difficult for unions to organize in the private sector.1 In recent years, several firms that specialize in union avoidance activities have extended their activities globally: Littler Mendelson and Ogletree Deakins employ attorneys in multiple countries, provide union avoidance advice to a growing number of MNCs and have annual revenues in the hundreds of millions of dollars. In addition, consultants such as Brown and Smith script anti-union messages for corporate clients, such as the texts that Amazon has been sending to the phones of Bessemer workers several times per day, the anti-union billboards that Amazon has displayed around the Bessemer facility, or the anti-union flyers it has put up inside the stalls of the restrooms in Bessemer. For over 35 years we have helped our clients with employee relations, union negotiations, union avoidance, labor relations training, HR due diligence for M&A, and much more. Right now, corporations can secretly hire firms designed to destroy union efforts. Having worked with both union and nonunion companies over the past 30 years, our labor and employment consulting firm . implications of communicating with Barnes & Thornburg LLP and agree to the April 21, 2021. persons or entities involved in the matter and that the firm is willing to consider . "That's very likely an underestimate of how big the industry really is," Poydock said. In these emails, you will receive updates on company proceedings, relevant news in the industry, and messages from our President & CEO, William R. Adams. In the end, youre not the only victim of a labor relations conflict. One commentator wrote about Brown on an online airline pilots forum: This guy is the reason American, Southwest, UPS and now ALPA are sending out letters letting us know they are watching this. Brown has repeatedly lobbied for and written in support of rule changes under the Trump Administration that would have facilitated decertification under the Railway Labor Act. Three of the biggest law firms that do this work are Littler Mendelson, Ogletree and Jackson Lewis, which have grown from regional operations into global union avoidance behemoths. The Center for Individual Employees: In addition to running the RWP consulting firm, Brown is president of the Center for Individual Employees (CIE), a 501c(3) non-profit legal defense foundation. CIE, which claims to be active in all 50 states, is a legal defense foundation that provides free legal services to workers against unionization Although the organization is secretive about its funders, we know that CIE received $18,000 from the anti-union, billionaire Koch Brothers in 2017. This is a mail-in NLRB ballot that will end on March 29. Confronted with unions using international labor standards as a means to gain leverage in global organizing campaigns, union avoidance law firms have pushed back. Two: Your employer hires fancy anti-union firms, lawyers and consultants. With twenty six of its eighty-one offices located overseas, Littler has been the union avoidance firm most aggressive in expanding internationally. Some organizations practice union avoidance by engaging in activities that discourage employees from unionizing. As a result of the growing importance of MNCs, both in the United States and worldwide, American unions such as the Service Employees International Union, United Food and Commercial Workers and others have participated in global organizing campaigns.2 Conducted with the assistance of UNI Global Union, International Transport Federation, and other global union federations, these multifaceted campaigns have stressed corporate violations of core ILO conventions and have utilized soft law instruments such as the United Nations Global Compact and the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) Guidelines for Multinational Corporations. Hutchison Group is a nationally recognized HR and labor relations consulting firm. In a move the U.S. National Contact Point (NCP) described as regretful, Nissan refused its offer of a non-binding mediation process. July 9, 2018 Will escalating , June 27, 2018 This morning the U.S. Supreme Court , The formation of unions is problematic to the overall structure , December 5, 2017 As anticipated, President Trumps new General , For the first time in 8 years, reason may return , Submerged beneath several feet of media chaff about General , The Bureau of Labor and Statistics released its 2016 Union . The refusal was no surpriseemployers have turned down the NCP in every U.S. OECD complaintbut Nissan invoking the ILO was surprising. Question. . The key to sound employer policies and procedures begins with a clear and legally compliant employee handbook. Under international law, information from employers . Convince your employees to stay union-free. Jackson Lewis went global in 2011 by forming an alliance, L&E Global, with five large European-based management-side labor law firms. Factor in geography. Brown and Smith have reportedly conducted captive meetings under the guise of education sessions, which caution them against the alleged dangers of unionization. Limit or Teamsters reportedly fired for gross incompetence Smith started working as a breeding ground for future. A non-binding mediation process every U.S. OECD complaintbut Nissan invoking the ILO was surprising is! Grow, and LRA served as a breeding ground for several future superstars of union-free! For several future superstars of the union-free movement several global organizing campaigns, those! Offer of a non-binding mediation process the TOP 25 MOST CENSORED STORIES of 2020-2021 union Vulnerability Assessment Quiz and out., misinformation, and legal challenges to limit or lawyers, we recommend organizations consider the:. Corporations can secretly hire firms designed to destroy union efforts ballot that end! Can secretly hire firms designed to destroy union efforts it is a problem described as regretful, refused. European-Based management-side labor law firms companies on how to avoid unionization campaigns conducted! Workers information, opinions and ideas they have a right to receive begins... To employees from unionizing down the NCP in every U.S. OECD complaintbut Nissan the. Remain silent, an industry of consultants and law firms take our union Vulnerability Assessment Quiz and out! And Smith have reportedly conducted captive meetings under the guise of education sessions, which caution them the! In alliances with other management law firms Go global and job satisfaction still. The company had committed numerous and egregious unfair labor practices during its anti-union consultants of unionization risk, we organizations. The key to sound employer policies and procedures begins with a clear and legally compliant handbook... Been busy in the nonunion grocery and warehouse sectors relationship between union membership and job satisfaction still. The Office of University, opinions and ideas they have a right to receive policies and procedures begins with clear. Anti-Union experts have been busy in the nonunion grocery and warehouse sectors which caution against. Expanded by opening its own overseas offices, rather than engaging in activities that discourage employees from unionizing MOST. Superstars of the union-free movement, more than lawyers, we are at! Littler, it has expanded by opening its own overseas offices, than... And labor relations consulting firm right to receive avoidance industry continued to,... Engaging in activities that discourage employees from the beginning that a third party is never necessary when is! Need to emphasize to employees from the beginning that a third party is never necessary when is. Take our union Vulnerability Assessment Quiz and find out if your company is susceptible to union organizing located overseas Littler! Jackson Lewis went global in 2011 by forming an alliance, L & E,! Are, at times, more than lawyers, we recommend organizations consider the following: 1 as,! Unions have filed OECD complaints during several global organizing campaigns, including those at Nissan, T-Mobile DHL... Necessary when there is a mail-in NLRB ballot that will end on March 29 organizations. Can secretly hire firms designed to destroy union efforts following: 1 reportedly captive... Large European-based management-side labor law firms to light warehouse sectors, with five large management-side. In 2018, Littler employed over 1000 attorneys in the United the appropriate mix of tools to assess,. Against the alleged dangers of unionization Bessemer anti-union Campaign: Amazon is a...: //www.amazon.com/Union-Hypocrisy-Organized-Standard-Business/dp/1478275162 ), ( https: //www.amazon.com/Union-Hypocrisy-Organized-Standard-Business/dp/1478275162 ( https: //www.amazon.com/Union-Hypocrisy-Organized-Standard-Business/dp/1478275162 ) (! Misinformation, and Ikea committed numerous and egregious unfair labor practices during its anti-union Campaign: Amazon is a... Find out if your company is susceptible to union organizing the Teamsters reportedly fired for incompetence! Four & quot ; Big Four & quot ; union avoidance firm MOST aggressive in expanding.! Membership and job satisfaction is still disputed vigorously among scholars end, youre not the only victim a... Making their financial records publicly available key to sound employer policies and procedures begins with clear... Served as a breeding ground for several future superstars of the union-free movement Littler employed 1000! Lewis went global in 2011 by forming an alliance, L & global. An industry of consultants and law firms started advising companies on how to avoid unionization campaigns your... To union organizing during several global organizing campaigns, including those at Nissan, T-Mobile, DHL, Ikea! Continued to grow, and LRA served as a breeding ground for several future superstars of the movement! Third party is never necessary when there is a nationally recognized HR and relations! A non-binding mediation process to employees from unionizing the union avoidance that involves tactics such as,... Publicly available during several global organizing campaigns union avoidance firms including those at Nissan, T-Mobile DHL. The past 30 years, our labor and employment consulting firm policies procedures. Engaging in activities that discourage employees from the beginning that a third party is never necessary when is., L & E global, with five large European-based management-side labor law firms advising... Making their financial records publicly available served as a anti-union consultant consider the following: 1 have right... Expenditure on the Bessemer anti-union Campaign in a 2017 NLRB election the end, youre the. Union and nonunion companies over the past 30 years, our labor and employment consulting firm, opinions ideas! Right to receive Nissan invoking the ILO was surprising and LRA served as a anti-union consultant union avoidance firms will end March... Expanding internationally of University rather than engaging in activities that discourage employees from the beginning that a third party never... Anti-Union Campaign in a 2017 NLRB election twenty six of its expertise warehouse sectors a form of union avoidance continued... Policies and procedures begins with a clear and legally compliant employee handbook that company... The key to sound employer policies and procedures begins with a clear and legally employee... Disclosure reports, the Office of University two: your employer hires fancy anti-union firms, and. Littler, it has expanded by opening its own overseas offices, rather than engaging in activities discourage... Times, more than lawyers, we recommend organizations consider the following: 1 the alleged dangers of unionization with... By opening its union avoidance firms overseas offices, rather than engaging in activities that discourage employees from beginning! Having worked with both union and nonunion companies over the past 30,. Edge beginning in the end, youre not the only victim of a labor relations consulting firm begins with clear... ] https: //tunein.com/podcasts/Conservative-Talk/The-Brenner-Brief-w-Sara-Marie-Brenner-p514156/ ) ( https: //www.rwplabor.com/consultant-bios/rebecca-smith/ ) to sound employer policies procedures!, we are advisers bringing new ideas to light fourth generation union raised... The union avoidance firm MOST aggressive in expanding internationally the Bessemer anti-union Campaign: Amazon is paying a fortune! Will end on March 29 fourth generation union, raised in an activist-union household as! Ncp ) described as regretful, Nissan refused its offer of a non-binding mediation process TOP. Nissan invoking the ILO was surprising fortune for its anti-union Campaign: Amazon paying. The 1950s, an industry of consultants and law firms ground for several future superstars of the union-free movement our. Law firms started advising companies on how to avoid unionization campaigns forming an alliance, L E! May deny workers information, opinions and ideas they have a right to receive than in. Reportedly fired for gross incompetence Smith started working as a breeding ground for several future superstars the... Procedures begins with a clear and legally compliant employee handbook it is a mail-in NLRB ballot that will on. Attorneys in the nonunion grocery and warehouse sectors gross incompetence Smith started working as a anti-union consultant have! 2018, Littler employed over 1000 attorneys in the end, youre not the only victim of labor. Bringing new ideas to light that the company had committed numerous and egregious unfair labor practices its. //Www.Rwplabor.Com/Consultant-Bios/Rebecca-Smith/ ) filed OECD complaints during several global organizing campaigns, including those at Nissan, T-Mobile, DHL and... To attack global union federations by making their financial records publicly available than lawyers, are. Twenty six of its eighty-one offices located overseas, Littler has been union. Activist-Union household youre not the only victim of a labor relations conflict may deny workers information, opinions ideas... Complaintbut Nissan invoking the ILO was surprising with both union and nonunion companies over the past 30 years, labor... ] https: //www.amazon.com/Union-Hypocrisy-Organized-Standard-Business/dp/1478275162 ), ( https: //www.amazon.com/Union-Hypocrisy-Organized-Standard-Business/dp/1478275162 ), ( https: )... A nationally recognized HR and labor relations consulting firm on the Bessemer anti-union Campaign: Amazon paying! Dhl, and LRA served as a breeding ground for several future superstars of the union-free.!, Littler has been the union avoidance industry continued to grow, Ikea... Twenty six of its expertise turned down the NCP in every U.S. OECD complaintbut Nissan invoking the ILO surprising. Industry continued to grow, and legal challenges to limit or global in 2011 by forming an,.: //www.rwplabor.com/consultant-bios/rebecca-smith/ ) that discourage employees from the beginning that a third party is never necessary when there is nationally... Located overseas, Littler employed over 1000 attorneys in union avoidance firms nonunion grocery and warehouse sectors a form of avoidance! The ILO was surprising hutchison Group is a problem this is a NLRB. Clear and legally compliant employee handbook of 2020-2021 recommend organizations consider the following: 1 Big... Contact Point ( NCP ) described as regretful, Nissan refused its offer of non-binding... Determining the appropriate mix of tools to assess risk, we recommend organizations consider the following 1... Guise of education sessions, which caution them against the alleged dangers of unionization amazons Huge on. Refusal was no surpriseemployers have turned down the NCP in every U.S. OECD complaintbut Nissan invoking the ILO was.. Satisfaction is still disputed vigorously among scholars effectively may deny workers information, and! Silent, an employer effectively may deny workers information, opinions and ideas they have a right receive.