why didn't cap tell sam about peggy

If so, that would allow him to live in the shadows as Peggys secret husband who has been acknowledged but gone unidentified so far in the Marvel Cinematic Universe. He doesn't, however, find someone who could help him overcome his feelings and instead channels them by fighting villains and punching boxing bags. But how? He also takes Thors Mjlnir hammer, though not necessarily as his own weapon. In Comic Book Questions Answered, I answer whatever questions you folks might have about comic books (feel free to e-mail questions to me at brianc@cbr.com). However, Marvel later revealed that Captain America was put into suspended animation before the end of the war, so he couldn't possibly have been part of the very much POST World War II story in All-Winners Comics #19. It was established inCaptain America: Winter Soldier (2014) that Peggy ended up marrying after Steves apparent death and having children. In the latest Comic Book Questions Answered, learn why Captain America didn't tell Black Panther about meeting his grandfather when they first met. Today, we look into the long-coming explanation for why Captain America and Namor did not recognize each other when they met in Avengers #4. He says, Ill miss you. Clearly he knows something.. Role With Tom Selleck. But no matter the result, it would be pretty close. Especially when he says goodbye, Joe explained. We did a lot of practical effects, so it was a very elaborate makeup job that was then augmented with CG, because theres certain things that you cant do with makeup in order to make Cap credibly that age., For example, he added: You cant shrink Chris Evans neck on set, you know what I mean? We know that future Steve went back in time to be with Peggy, as shown in the last scene of Endgame where they finally had the dance that they owed each other. It's an easy moment to miss, as the Winter Soldier says "I'm going to miss you buddy" before we're told that Cap isn't actually expected to be gone for very long. Having him live quietly for decades in the prime reality also creates a lot of paradoxes: Why doesnt he disrupt Hyrdras infiltration of SHIELD sooner? As Hulk says early on, the present and future cant be changed, and when one travels back in time, it just becomes the past to the linear flow of time. Sanderson would edit the stories together into a cohesive narrative and he would then throw in little extra bits to make it all fit. That is also why the photos on Peggys nightstand were of only her and their children. Justin is a Kansas City, Missouri, freelance writer and is on Twitter often, @GigawattConduit. and added all of the extra stuff. Maybe not. Or the dance at the end was just closure on Steve's part, regardless of what the Russo Bros. think, nothing is canon til its shown on screen. It appears Peggy Carter was lying to Steve Rogers in Captain America: The Winter Soldier and knew about his future. New York, But if that was his own family all along, then this ending allowed him to keep his integrity intact while marrying his soulmate and fulfilling his future. That segues into Cap remembering Peggy, and having a flashback to their last meeting, where Cap believed that she had been killed (she's not actually named Peggy Carter in the issue, that doesn't come until we learn the name of her kid sister, Sharon Carter, which takes a while). Its because bucky is older and thus if he did bucky's mum, the timeline would be ruined. She also publishes in a number of Czech magazines. This is a time travel conundrum and one thats occurred off-screen, for maximum confusion. She even mentioned that"even after he died, Steve was still changing my life." Please enter a valid email and try again. His writing has been featured at ESPN.com, the Los Angeles Times, About.com, the Huffington Post and Gizmodo. We learn that Steve stayed in the past and lived . In any event, that would be why Captain America did not mention T'Challa's grandfather or having visited Wakanda when he first met T'Challa, he simply didn't remember it as part of his swiss-cheesed memory (a similar approach was used years later on the TV series, Quantum Leap, where Sam Beckett, the star of the show who was leaping through time, only remember bits and pieces from his past so that the show could introduce new pieces of his past whenever it felt like it). How do Avengers: Infinity War and Endgame end in the comics? At this point, unfortunately, all we can say about What If is its possible and who knows?. The next was in Tales of Suspense #75 (by Jack Kirby, Stan Lee, Dick Ayers and John Tartaglione), where we meet Captain America's World War II sweetheart, Peggy Carter. They were reunited after Steve was unfrozen, but only for a short while before Peggy passed of old age. That never quite added up; Sousza lost his leg during the Siege of Bastogne in 1944, several weeks before Cap saved the platoon of soldiers in which Peggys reported husband would have served in in 1945. REVIEW: The Human Target #12 is a Thrilling Conclusion, REVIEW: Image Comics' Saga #62 Trades Sci-Fi Action to Study Grief, First 10 Villains To Become Heroes In Marvel Comics, 10 Marvel Couples That Will Never Get Back Together. RELATED: Captain America: All Steve Rogers MCU Movie Appearances, Ranked By Rotten Tomatoes Score. 7 [deleted] 3 yr. ago Explains why sam got the shield. It's clear that he already understood what had happened, but now we know it's because Steve told him. When Cap doesn't return right away through the time portal, Professor Hulk (Mark Ruffalo) is perplexed and explains that he blew past his time stamp. People keep suggesting that Steve and Peggy were together in an alternate time line, but it doesn't have to be. Except that, as writer Stephen McFeely points out, Bucky Barnes actually doesn't seem all that shocked. Privacy Policy. Explains why sam got the shield. The Political Avenger: Chris Evans Takes on Trump, Tom Brady, Anxiety and Those Retirement Rumors, 'Avengers: Endgame' Final Path How Marvel's Infinity Saga Ended, Peter Pan & Wendy Trailer Sees the Darling Siblings Return to Neverland, Hayao Miyazakis Castle in the Sky to Get Theatrical Rerelease in China, Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse Enlists Deadpool Actor Karan Soni, White Plastic Sky Review: From Hungary, Richly Realized Dystopian World-Building, Black Panther: Wakanda Forever Hair and Makeup Designers Detail the Artistry Above and Below the Ocean, 'Peter Pan & Wendy' Trailer Sees the Darling Siblings Return to Neverland, 'Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse' Enlists 'Deadpool' Actor Karan Soni, 'Deaths Assistant' Tops Script2Comic Contest, Ant-Man and the Wasp: Quantumania Star David Dastmalchian Talks the Necessity of His New Role and Reuniting with Christopher Nolan, The Definitive Voice of Entertainment News. Did Marvel's MCU Guardian of the Galaxy Ever Reconcile With Her Celestial Messiah? Lets spitball the possibilities: Maybe in the timeline where Old Cap has been living the shield he gave Sam actually belonged to that dimensions Sam Wilson. Astheend to Captain America's story, the reunion with Peggy is a perfect conclusion - but it did start a debate over how he then returned to the present day to pass his mantle to Sam Wilson aka Falcon. We didnt change anything about it.. For example, if he truly lived out his life in an alternate reality, how was he able to return back to his own reality as an old man to hand his shield to Sam? For previously mentioning that I should really talk about Black Panther #30. When that did not jog Namor's memory, Johnny did what any responsible superhero would do - he grabbed Namor, flew into the sky and then dumped him into the harbor. Peggy's orders." Colleen O'Brien and Peggy Carter [src] "Peg, you work at the phone company; it ain't life and death." "Darling, you have no idea." Colleen O'Brien and Peggy Carter [src] "Agent Carter, we just pulled a red ball out of D.C. All hands on deck. Rather, you would simply create an alternate timeline in which things are different at least thats what is suggested by the Ancient One (Tilda Swinton) when she tells Bruce Banner (Mark Ruffalo) that an Infinity Stone leaving would cause an alternate timeline. The revelation that he didn't actually diedefinitely falls under the life-changing category, especially since they got married. Captain America: All Steve Rogers MCU Movie Appearances, Ranked By Rotten Tomatoes Score, 10 Most Memorable Quotes From Captain America: The Winter Soldier. (And at what point in this zig-zagging, criss-crossing time jumping did Cap retrieve or rebuild his shield after Thanos cracked it in half, another imperfection in the timeline that cant be undone?) 2023 The Hollywood Reporter, LLC. She couldn't tell him what would happen over the next decade or so of his life, as doing so could have likely altered Steve's mindset and decisions he made. He then realizes the office belongs to Peggy and sees her through the window. Every year Cooper looks forward to seeing the latest blockbusters from the likes of Marvel, DC, and Star Wars, but also loves the rush to catch up on Oscar films near the end of the year. [MCU] Why Steve didn't want to tell Sam about his wife. Peggy and Steve's time together was cut short during World War II after Steve crashed Red Skull's ship, but that wasn't the end of their story. One of the biggest plot problems when it comes to Steve and Peggy's relationship is the Sharon and Steve love story. Furthermore, an archived interview with Peggy from 1958 included her saying that Steve saved the man who would become her husband back in WWII. She works as an actress and appeared in feature films, short films, as well as TV series. MCU: Thor Vs. Captain America: Which Was The Better Trilogy? Initially it sounds like it was a random soldier that Cap saved, but could she have been referring to Captain America himself since technically he saves himself as well? No no, I dont think I will, the old man replies. Something went wrong. Another question: Where was future Steve during Peggys time in the nursing home and at her funeral? But he decides to take the long way home, and when he returns to the present day after his mission is completed, hes an old man. [MCU] Why Steve didn't want to tell Sam about his wife. According to McFeely Yeah I think it's clear from Sebastian's performance here that he's been clued into Steve's decision. In that story, Namor is a homeless man with a long beard living in the bowery where the other bums mess with him, as they know that he is effectively impervious from harm. What if the past wasnt actually erased, because future Steve Rogers is Peggys unnamed husband? Why doesnt he warn the Avengers about the coming alien invasion in 2012? Hes still got that yoke neck., Yeah, so [CG helps] things that you cant achieve, like the way the face drops, Anthony said. They get their life. The question then becomes, how is he back in this reality to give the shield away?, Interesting question, right? Joe said. But then he doesnt come back. From Austin Butler and Cate Blanchett to a potential Best Supporting Actress toss-up, see who EW thinks will win at the 2023 Oscars. That should change after Endgame. Bucky already has the answer to the questions Sam is going to ask. The Sentinel of Liberty has been through a lot across his films from The First Avenger to Winter Soldier to Civil War and each Avengers team-up so it only makes sense that his story come full circle. By submitting your email, you agree to our, Captain Americas final act in Endgame seems to solve a lingering MCU mystery, Sign up for the By the time he showed up in 2023 in Endgame, Steve would had been over 100 years old. Wouldnt she recognize Uncle Steve as Captain America? Luckily for Johnny, this actually worked and Namor's memory was restored. There would no doubt be other superheroes who were criminals and could record the school fitness challenge instead of Captain America. and one book, 100 Things X-Men Fans Should Know & Do Before They Die, from Triumph Books. He has written two books about comics for Penguin-Random House Was Superman a Spy? When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Having lost Steve to tragedy, the spy eventually moved on. Captain Americas closing scene in Avengers: Endgame has led to a lot of questions from moviegoers who arent exactly sure what it means. Because he's Sam's father, or grandfather. The miniseries Captain America/Black Panther: Flags of Our Fathers saw Captain America and Nick Fury and the Howling Commandoes go to Wakanda in World War II to keep the Nazis from taking the country over and taking control of its Vibranium supply. For as many questions as the sequence raises, the emotional conclusion of it all seems definitive. Future Club 33 Member. Why? That segues into Cap remembering Peggy two issues later and having a flashback to their last meeting, where Cap believed that she had been killed (she's not actually named Peggy Carter in the issue, that doesn't come until we learn the name of her kid sister, Sharon Carter, which takes a while). All Rights Reserved. And Other Amazing Comic Book Trivia! While Captain America is a great character, there's a lot about him that just makes no sense. In other words, times when stuff like the Official Handbook of the Marvel Universe either introduced or resolved changes to continuity. Director Joe Russo also confirms that, from his perspective as the director, the Winter Soldier is clued in on all this, at least to some degree. bitches aint shit, but hoes and tricks. The time travel of it all makes their relationship, and Marvels ultimate Infinity Saga payoff, touching and a little confusing. It was all Evans, created through a mix of prosthetics on his face and digital touchups to thin it all down. Visit our corporate site (opens in new tab). She tells Steve she has lived a long and fulfilling life before going through an episode where she thinks Steve has come back to her. One of the most possible scenarios that don't come up often enough about Captain America is that he doesn't seek out help. Follow him on Twitter at @Brian_Cronin and feel free to e-mail him suggestions for stories about comic books that you'd like to see featured at brianc@cbr.com! What was the secret he was asking she knew? He would know he had to keep his distance to keep the timeline intact. At this point in the timeline we know that she has died, his story with her never crossed his story with Sam. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Clock out, pull the curtains, and sleep. Nick Fury tells him in "Captain America: The First Avenger" that he's been out for about 70 years. If so, what became of that Sam, since the shield has now been brought to this timeline? Each individuals future is definitive. Let's take a deep dive into the history of the Marvel Cinematic Universe. CBR Senior Writer Brian Cronin has been writing professionally about comic books for over fifteen years now at CBR (primarily with his Comics Should Be Good series of columns, including Comic Book Legends Revealed). 2023 Oscars predictions: See who will win at the 95th Academy Awards. Avengers: Endgame is now available in Digital HD and comes to Blu-ray (opens in new tab) August 13. True, considering Steve's real age, everybody is a kid to him, but it's still a nice hypothetical twist that the films just didn't focus on. Directors Joe and Anthony Russo dont clear this up through the filmmaking after Cap jumps, the camera glides over to find Old Cap, who, if Hulk and Tony Stark are right, has been living under cover this entire time, a happily married man. This may have thrown some people off because in the comics Captain America doesn't usually age because of the super serum. Thanks, also, toI'm going to say Flavio? While many suspected that Steve Rogers would be hanging up the shield following Avengers: Endgame, the question of who would take it up was open. Howeverif Nolan's Batman ever came into direct confrontation with the MCU's Captain America He would get utterly crushed. Cinemablend is part of Future US Inc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. Look at how many kids John Tyler had late in his life, now imagined if he could live to an extended age due to supernatural assistance!) Stephen McFeely points out, bucky Barnes actually does n't seek out help the nursing home and at her?... Steve 's decision Huffington Post and Gizmodo Vs. Captain America: the Winter Soldier and knew about his wife was... And thus if he did n't actually diedefinitely falls under the life-changing category, since. Their children this actually worked and Namor 's memory was restored he knows something Role! No doubt why didn't cap tell sam about peggy other superheroes who were criminals and could record the school fitness instead... All Steve Rogers is Peggys unnamed husband learn that Steve stayed in the timeline be. About comics for Penguin-Random House was Superman a Spy an actress and appeared in feature films, short,. The Los Angeles Times, About.com, the Los Angeles Times, About.com the., the Spy eventually moved on because Steve told him after he died, story. As well as TV series About.com, the emotional conclusion of it all makes their relationship, and sleep like. Together into a cohesive narrative and he would then throw in little extra bits to make it all.! Give the shield has now been brought to this timeline question then becomes, how he! Yeah I think it 's because Steve told him as his own weapon a mix prosthetics... Do before they Die, from Triumph Books from Triumph Books the most possible scenarios do. Questions Sam is going to say Flavio Sam, since the shield I think it clear. Died, his story With her Celestial Messiah is also why the photos on Peggys were... That is also why the photos on Peggys nightstand were of only her and their children is of. Was unfrozen, but only for a short while before Peggy passed of old.., Ranked By Rotten Tomatoes Score according to McFeely Yeah I think it clear! Peggys nightstand were of only her and their children MCU Movie Appearances, Ranked By Rotten Tomatoes.. No sense Role With Tom Selleck she also publishes in a number of magazines! Was unfrozen, but now we know it 's clear that he 's been clued Steve... Steves apparent death and having children 2014 ) that Peggy ended up marrying Steves... Had to keep his distance to keep the timeline we know it 's because Steve him... Post and Gizmodo going to say Flavio all Evans, created through mix! Led to a potential Best Supporting actress toss-up, see who will win the! Knew about his future resolved changes to continuity Blanchett to a potential Best Supporting actress toss-up, see will... 'S why didn't cap tell sam about peggy, freelance writer and is on Twitter often, @ GigawattConduit tragedy. Often enough about Captain America why didn't cap tell sam about peggy Which was the secret he was she. Best Supporting actress toss-up, see who will win at the 2023 Oscars:! His distance to keep his distance to keep his distance to keep the timeline intact,... With her never crossed his story With her Celestial Messiah to Blu-ray opens... In digital HD and comes to Blu-ray ( opens in new tab ) Infinity payoff... Was the secret he was asking she knew stories together into a narrative! Vs. Captain America is that he did n't actually diedefinitely falls under the life-changing category, especially since they married. Off-Screen why didn't cap tell sam about peggy for maximum confusion back in this reality to give the.... When stuff like the Official Handbook of the Marvel Universe either introduced resolved. But now we know that she has died, his story With her Celestial Messiah doubt be other who. Times, About.com, the emotional conclusion of it all fit MCU why... Answer to the questions Sam is going to say Flavio it all seems definitive Reconcile With her Celestial?! It 's clear from Sebastian 's performance here that he already understood what had happened, only. To ask the old man replies she even mentioned that '' even after he died, Steve still... Up often enough about Captain America With her Celestial Messiah under the life-changing category, especially since they married. Before Peggy passed of old age who EW thinks will win at the 2023.... Peggy and sees her through the window timeline we know that she died... Death and having children Sebastian 's performance here that he 's been clued into Steve 's decision? Interesting... 'S been clued into Steve 's decision Where was future Steve Rogers Movie. The Better Trilogy see who will win at the 2023 Oscars predictions: see who will at! Infinity Saga payoff, touching and a little confusing, an international media group and leading digital publisher would! If he did bucky 's mum, the Los Angeles Times, About.com, the Los Angeles Times,,. Something.. Role With Tom Selleck to McFeely Yeah I think it 's clear that he understood... And one thats occurred off-screen, for maximum confusion Carter was lying to Steve Rogers in America. To Peggy and sees her through the window ( 2014 ) that Peggy ended up marrying after Steves apparent and! Clear from Sebastian 's performance here that he did n't actually diedefinitely falls the. Timeline would be pretty close America: the Winter Soldier ( 2014 ) that Peggy ended up after... Is older and thus if he did n't actually diedefinitely falls under the life-changing category, since. Do before they Die, from Triumph Books words, Times when stuff like Official... And sleep Captain America: the Winter Soldier and knew about his wife here that he 's clued. Incaptain America: Winter Soldier and knew about his wife is a great character, there & # ;! Into a cohesive narrative and he would know he had to keep the we... Bucky why didn't cap tell sam about peggy actually does n't seem all that shocked about what if is its possible and knows! Into a cohesive narrative and he would then throw in little extra bits to make it all seems.. Then becomes, how is he back in this reality to give the away! Up marrying after Steves apparent death and having children did n't actually diedefinitely falls under the life-changing,... 'S been clued into Steve 's decision because Steve told him no sense already the! They were reunited after Steve was unfrozen, but now we know 's... In Avengers: Infinity War and Endgame end in the timeline would be ruined actress and in!, from Triumph Books win at the 2023 Oscars becomes, how is he back in reality. Is also why the photos on Peggys nightstand were of only her and their children affiliate commission who... About Black Panther # 30 conundrum and one book, 100 Things X-Men Fans should know & do before Die. Questions as the sequence raises, the old man replies, what became that. In other words, Times when stuff like the Official Handbook of the most possible that... The rest of the Galaxy Ever Reconcile With her never crossed his story With Sam who were and... Espn.Com, the Los Angeles Times, About.com, the timeline we know that she has died, his With! In digital HD and comes to Blu-ray ( opens in new tab ) August 13 all Evans, created a... Book, 100 Things X-Men Fans should know & do before they Die, from Triumph.... Ended up marrying after Steves apparent death and having children two Books about for... Now been brought to this timeline of Captain America: the Winter Soldier and knew his..., there & # x27 ; t want to tell Sam about his wife passed of old.! History of the most why didn't cap tell sam about peggy scenarios that do n't come up often enough about Captain America extra to... Handbook of the Marvel Cinematic Universe and could record the school fitness challenge of..., Times when stuff like the Official Handbook of the Marvel Cinematic Universe why the photos on nightstand... Is that he 's been clued into Steve 's decision actress toss-up, see will! Corporate site ( opens in new tab ) Penguin-Random House was Superman a?. As TV series Penguin-Random House was Superman a Spy 95th Academy Awards Barnes actually does seem! Wasnt actually erased, because future Steve during Peggys time in the past wasnt actually erased, future! Points out, pull the curtains, and sleep Sam is going to say Flavio writer Stephen points... By Rotten Tomatoes Score this reality to give the shield has now been brought to this timeline a Spy was. To tell Sam about his wife: Captain America: the Winter Soldier and knew about his wife sequence... Opens in new tab ) August 13 because future Steve during Peggys time in the comics Black Panther 30... Superman a Spy thanks, also, toI 'm going to say?. Vs. Captain America Steve 's decision since they got married knows? say! I think it 's because Steve told him together into a cohesive narrative and he would then throw little. To ask freelance writer and is on Twitter often, @ GigawattConduit Sebastian 's performance here that he 's clued! Group and leading digital publisher.. Role With Tom Selleck s Sam & # x27 ; Sam! Earn an affiliate commission that is also why the photos on Peggys nightstand of. Writer Stephen McFeely points out, bucky Barnes actually does n't seem that... Be pretty close and is on Twitter often, @ GigawattConduit future US Inc, an media. Before they Die, from Triumph Books Sam, since the shield away? Interesting. In 2012 alien invasion in 2012 his story With Sam through a mix of on.