Capano then retrieved the cooler, removed the body, and wrapped the anchor chains around it. He'd pick them up in his electrician van. He is currently serving his sentence in prison. He also confessed to bombing an abortion clinic in Georgia, a lesbian bar in Georgia, and an abortion clinic in Birmingham, Alabama resulting in the death of an Alabaman security guard and a police officer. Simpson, but nothing ever came of it. "The human body taste was very similar to pork. He lived on a farm in Indiana with his wife of 25 years and had three children. This is a list of notable male murderers who committed their murders in Delaware, USA. [11], A 2000 episode of The FBI Files, title "Deadly Obsession,"[12] and an episode of the CBS News documentary program 48 Hours featured the case. Terry is not the only member of the Blair family who has a murderous past. Corll almost got away with the murders of almost 30 young boys because no one suspected him; he was a straight-laced man who worked at his mother's candy factory. They were given the name "Sex Slave Killers.". Eugene Butler was declared mentally insane in 1906 and died in an asylum a few years later. She became notorious for her illegal activity, including murder, crime, and theft, and striking fear into the hearts of Americans. His preferred method: having his victim lay down and shooting them in the back of the head. Meyers body was never found. This True Story About One Delaware Hero Is Nearly Unbelievable, Youll Actually Enjoy The History Lessons Found At This Quirky Delaware Pub, Few People Know That A Revolutionary War Battle Took Place In This Delaware Town, Most People Dont Know About These Strange Ruins Hiding In Delaware, This Is The Oldest Place You Can Possibly Go In Delaware And Its History Will Fascinate You, These 12 Photos Of Delaware From The Early 1900s Are Beyond Fascinating, 8 Nostalgic Places Around Delaware That Will Take You Back To Your Childhood, History Left A Definite Mark At This One Fascinating Spot In Delaware, The One Place To Sleep In Delaware Thats Beyond Your Wildest Dreams. Before his arrest, Capanos brother Gerard Capano told investigators he helped his brother dump a body from a boat off the Jersey shore. When Cowgill owned the spot, it was a stop on the Underground Railroad. Of those 18, five people were killed. (AP Photo/Matthew S. Gunby), Assistant U.S. Attorney Colm Connolly, right, answers questions from the media as Delaware State Prosecutor Ferris Wharton, center, and Deleware Attorney General Jane Brady, left, listen after a jury convicted Thomas J. Capano for first-degree murder in the death of Anne Marie Fahey. 23 people were injured, but somehow there were no deaths. Workers building the Fox Run apartment complex found her body at 6:25 the next morning. Ross became a devote Catholic while in prison, and supported the death sentence against him saying he did not want to cause his victims families any more pain. Rogers may be the murderer of Nicole Simpson not O.J. What his wife didn't know was that Herb also cruised gay bars at night, picking up young men. Upon their arrivals he told them he had gifts for them but wanted to give them their presents one by one. He is still in prison, 10 young people, earning him the title "The Co-ed Killer, convinced the FBI to let him out as an informant. He was put to death in 2010. If you mix it together no one can tell the difference," he told The Sun in 2015. With roughly 60 members, it was the states third-largest police department for a time. The group operated for about a decade in the early 19th century and abducted hundreds of free Black people and fugitive slaves, along the Delmarva Peninsula, across multiple . Pages in category "People convicted of murder by Delaware" The following 10 pages are in this category, out of 10 total. In the '90s, Metheny would lure sex workers to his trailer to stab and strangle them. Check out this list: Want to see them all in one go? On Oct.8, 1898, the Lewes newspaper, Delaware Pilot, reported, Governor (James)Budd, of California, on Wednesday decided that Mrs. Cordelia Botkin must come here (California)to stand trial for the murder of Mrs. John P. Dunning and Mrs. Joshua Deane.. Since he was a minor at the time, he has not been sentenced for those crimes. Route40 was the only connection between the two victims. Last but not least on our list of tales so scary they seem like Delaware ghost stories is that of the Route 40 Killer. Soon, undercover female officers dressed as prostitutes walked the stretch of highway looking for clues. Steven Brian Pennell is the state of Delawares only known serial killer. The bureau concluded the unthinkable: A serial killer had come to Delaware. Nearly everything burned to the ground in 1892, leaving 300 people homeless and burning one body so badly that it could not be identified. We felt that the same person was responsible for both murders.. Gordons body washed up on the rocky banks of the Chesapeake & Delaware Canal on Sept. 20. Access your favorite topics in a personalized feed while you're on the go. During the summer of 1969, The Manson Family carried out several murders. The lone witness to the abduction knew both Gordon and Pennell. Woodburn, the Governor's Mansion, is one of the most haunted places in Delaware. The American government kept many of these reports quiet, but German U-Boats sank many merchant ships off the coast of Delaware. John Joubert once said that when he was young he fantasized about killing his babysitter and eating her. It was hard to get into a conversation. Visit Insider's homepage for more stories. With modern technology, theres still hope that Janes killer will be brought to justice. When 10 women were murdered in the mid-'90s in Charlotte, North Carolina, they all had one thing in common: They all knew Henry Louis Wallace. [1][2] The medical examiner determined that Capano died of sudden cardiac arrest. There was no reason for Shirley Ellis to be killed,recalls Kathleen Jennings, the state prosecutor who eventually stared the accused down in a tough cross-examination. In the '90s, Paul Dennis Reid moved to Nashville to become a country music star. They went to Stone Harbor, New Jersey, with a large cooler that contained Fahey's body,[citation needed] sailed 62 miles (100km) out to sea, and pushed the cooler overboard. As they were chased away, one caught himself in a tree and hanged until his death. Shawn Grate was taken out of the home in handcuffs and later confessed to killing five women. Capano did not appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court, bringing an end to his appeals. As can be expected, until all of these murders are solved, Dover murders discussion will resume on social media outlets such as Facebook, Reddit, and Websleuths, where users consider the details of cases by speculating and sharing information regarding Dover murders pictures, Dover murders crime scene photos, and Dover, Delaware, murders autopsy photos, which are almost never released to the general public, although some are released once the criminal trial is completed. Meirhofer was one of the first serial killers to be identified using FBI's newly developed profiling system that helped catch countless other serial killers. Not every murder gets solved. In 2003, he roamed the streets of Connecticut in his van that he dubbed his "murder mobile." Hasen died in prison in 2014 while serving 461+ years. They called Donald Henry Gaskins "Pee Wee." She was one of the loveliest, kindest persons Ive ever hadthe privilege of serving with. [3] In September 1995, while still involved with Capano, Fahey began another relationship with Michael Scanlan.[4]. No one would ever look at his background and see signs that this could happen. Taschner estimates the van drove past her seven times in 20 minutes. Once caught, Charlene turned on Gerald in return for a shorter sentence. However, Capano's other mistress, Debby MacIntyre, had bought a gun and admitted having supplied the weapon to Capano.[2]. A cocaine addict, she was the only victim who died while being tortured. Its so moving and some of the stories bring me to tears not because its sad, but because its relatable and shows that were not alone. Kendra. William Devin Howell can best be described as a drifter. Just as fast as the killings started, they suddenly stopped. The van stopped. There have only been two serial killers to ever make the record here: Patty Cannon, in the 1820s, and Steven Brian Pennell, in the 1980s. Alaska has more serial killings per its population size than any other state, according to HuffPost. Pennell delivered a terse argument for his own death, filled with biblical quotes. After Lopez's arrest in 1980, police found the graves of more than 50 of his preteen victims. On January 17, 1999, the jury convicted Capano of first-degree murder and he was sentenced to death by lethal injection. Eric Robert Rudolph was an American domestic terrorist convicted of several anti-abortion and anti-gay bombings across the Southern United States between 1996 and 1998. David Parker Ray bought a $100,000 trailer. Taschner even sat next to Pennell at a Moody Blues concert. The 23-year-old had distanced herself from the life of a streetwalker, even purchasing books for nursing school. All of this thanks to a gas leak in the kitchen. As the bodies began to pile up, investigators struggled to find the culprit. In the years to come, the "Weepy-voiced killer" would be identified as Paul Michael Stephani. However, not all of our history is peaceful and calm. This time, however, police caught a break. A week later, officers from the Delaware State Police and the New Castle County Police Department sprang into action. Pennell asked if he could proceed without an attorney. ", Amy Anderson was the only woman to escape the clutches of Robert Leroy Anderson, authorities call him a serial killer that would have killed again if he had not been stopped, Corll had killed 28 boys in Texas just outside of Houston, He and the other accomplice are now serving their life sentence in prison, sentenced to death and met the electric chair in 1989, link him to a couple's murder in Burlington, Vermont, who killed four women in Southern Virginia, found guilty of raping and killing four women. In the mid-'80s the tropical utopia was gripped with fear when five bodies were found near water. In October 1976, Thomas Warren Whisenhant abducted Cheryl Lynn Payton from the convenience store where she worked. 2001). He then waited for the rest of his children to come to house. In 1892, Fall River, Massachusetts buzzed with talk of the 19th century's most incendiary story - that well-to-do local couple, Abby and Andrew Borden, died at the hands of an axe-wielder. Known as a prostitute to local authorities, Gordon was last seen on Route 40, hopping into the passenger side of a blue Ford panel van. The suspect had been pulled over for a routine traffic violation and was immediately hauled into court to pay his ticketan infrequent but legal method for the police to detain a suspect. The town of Texarkana which spanned Texas and Arkansas lived in fear, as he apparently attacked eight people and killed five. 1932, he killed and robbed five people, according to the New York Daily News, 22 bodies of men who the innkeeper had allegedly killed, 6 of the most notorious serial killers who were never caught, The most infamous crime committed in every state, FBI data reveals some of the most violent cities in nearly every state, An expert reveals the 12 key traits common in serial killers, and some of them might surprise you. He was convicted in 1976, and was executed after several appeals by lethal injection in 2010. I hoped and prayed that, before Pennell died, hed tell us where we could find Kathleen Meyer, or at least give us a place to look,says Hedrick. The day after Christmas when his extended family arrived at the house, Simmons shot his children and their spouses before strangling their two infant children and his 7-year-old granddaughter. Learn more about Social Responsibility at WHYY. Michelle Gordon, a 22-year-old New Castle resident, disappeared on Sept. 16, 1988. She became notorious for her illegal activity, including murder, crime, and theft, and striking fear into the hearts of Americans. The state responded by indicting Pennell for the murders of Meyer and Gordon, based on new evidence. more serial killers than any other country, he terrorized the Phoenix, Arizona, community in the summer of 2006, his nine death sentences were upheld in Phoenix. Barnabet killed entire families as they slept in what became known as the "Voodoo Murders" in the 1910s. Police believed the murders were the act of a serial killer, but could never find the culprit. The young woman was murdered in cold blood, screaming for help, and the neighbors who . He was found guilty of raping and killing four women and was put to death in 1994. On February 17, 2023, detectives from the Delaware State Police [] Read More Delaware State Police Investigating Homicide Date Posted: Saturday, February 18th, 2023 On Oct. 8, 1898, the Lewes newspaper, Delaware Pilot, reported, "Governor (James) Budd, of California, on Wednesday decided that Mrs. Cordelia Botkin must come here (California) to stand trial. It may surprise you to learn that the small state of Delaware holds more than its fair share of haunted locations. So although it's hard to choose just one killer that terrorized the state, Robert Hansen seems to leave a really bone-chilling scare. He was only found guilty of one murder and was sent to a mental institution. He is even said to have worn a mask made from the skin of one of the victims. Police found a strangled woman's body hiding under a pile of clothes. Some serial killers are known for killing children, like David Meirhofer in Montana. Contact: kmagaraci@onlyinyourstate.com. Delaware was the scene of the crime, but the authorities decided that the murder trial would be held in California. Although Carroll Edward Cole's crimes weren't committed in Iowa, he grew up in the state that seemingly shaped his life into a serial killer. After a notorious escape from prison, she later died from a heart attack. For the most part, Delaware is a peaceful state. How a Delaware man now suspected in four murders avoided prison after violating probation. He claimed he picked up DiMauro, paid her $25 for oral sex and then dropped her off, joking that she gave me $10 backafterward. Want a digest of WHYYs programs, events & stories? In fact, he was called "The Candy Man." Her gang of 50 to 60 people operated for 30 years, committing as many as 30 murders and more than 3,000 . WILMINGTON, Del. He was executed by lethal injection in 1990. The way he described DiMauro was so cold,says Jennings. Technically, Charles Starkweather is a spree killer but that doesn't make him any less terrifying. I asked women to be honest about their Instagram photos, Every Authentic American Horror Story Thats Inspired AHS (So Far), 21 Morgue Workers Share Their Worst Of Stories, A Woman Went To A Funeral To Berate A Grieving Mother, It Turns Out Her Daughter Might Be The Murderer, The Unaired Reality Dating Show In Which A Literal Murderer Got Third Place. But investigators believe this serial killer murdered at least 11 people around the country. If you're fascinated by Delaware's WWII history, check out this, In the 1970s, two tankers collided in the. Her wrists and ankles were bound, and she was silenced with duct tape. Please give today. One of the world's most prolific serial killers might still be out there. A few examples of the unsolved murders in northern Delaware include the 2013 murder of Kaiheem White, the 1993 murder of Linda Ann Moody Armstrong, the 2000 murder of Carmen Rodriguez, the 2013 murder of Lamar Wilmer, and the 2013 murder of Samantha Neuwein, among countless others. 7-year-old girl in Michigan was abducted and strangled to death, one of the first serial killers to be identified using FBI's newly developed profiling system, the couple killed 10 teenagers in Nevada and California, New Hampshire, he was known as "Bob Evans" who killed one woman and three small children, he killed upwards of 40 people over his 16-year career as a nurse, , he cut them into pieces and threw their bodies into lakes and ravines, The police were suddenly struck by a smell escaping from the trunk of his car, they found the bodies of six boys and young men buried under the floorboards. For the most part, Delaware is a peaceful state. He never permitted the interviews that got us answers, says Jennings. autobiography called "Final Truth: The Autobiography of a Serial Killer. Dubbed the "Serial Killer Clown," Gacy killed 33 boys and young men in the '70s. After a notorious escape from prison, she later died from a heart attack. Finally, a few examples of unsolved murders in Kent County, Delaware, include the 2015 murder of Douglas Kimball, the 1990 murder of Lena Lorraine Thomas, the 1983 murder of Shirley Weckerly, and the 2009 murder of Robert Watkins, among many others. All five were women ranging in age from 17 to 36, Hawaii News Now reports. Capano belonged to a prominent family of Delaware real estate developers and building contractors. We've collected five of the most notorious cold cases in American history, ranging from 1892 to 1996. . This famed accommodation has 13 rooms and at least three are reported to be haunted. OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. In 2001, a television movie based on Rule's book was made, And Never Let Her Go, starring Mark Harmon as Capano and Kathryn Morris as Fahey. He is currently serving his 10 life sentences in prison. Bruce Bennett was stabbed and bludgeoned to death, while his wife Debra was sexually assaulted before being bludgeoned to death as well. Her body was completely hairless, a side effect of exposure to arsenic. Eventually, an undercover cop was picked up by Pennell and she noticed his van was covered in blue carpet. he killed three boys, strangling them and taking bites into each. Thomas Warren Whisenhant was convicted of raping, mutilating, and murdering 3 women in Mobile County, Alabama in the 1970s. One example is the Uniform Crime Report, or UCR, that is released annually by the Federal Bureau of investigation. He is currently serving four life sentences at the ADX Florence Supermax in Colorado. Read more about it here: The One Place To Sleep In Delaware Thats Beyond Your Wildest Dreams. B Billy Bailey C Thomas Capano James B. Clark Jr. Cheney Clow D William Devonshire J Shannon Johnson (murderer) P Steven Brian Pennell R James Allen Red Dog S Nelson Shelton Ridgway said he would kidnap runaways and sex workers along the Route 99 and take them to his home. When the shells did not sink the ship, they put it into its grave with another torpedo. He is still in prison. Jurors spent eight days reviewing the evidence, which is still the longest deliberation in Delaware legal history. Get more stories delivered right to your email. The court unanimously agreed that execution was an appropriate punishment for Pennells crimes. He helped his brother dump a body from a heart attack loveliest kindest! Many of these reports quiet, but could never find the culprit a minor at the ADX Supermax. Declared mentally insane in 1906 and died in prison in 2014 while 461+..., theres still hope that Janes killer will be brought to justice Michael Scanlan. 4. Programs, events & stories having his victim lay down and shooting them in the of... Also cruised gay bars at night, picking up young men a strangled woman 's hiding!, Metheny would lure Sex workers to his trailer to stab and them! Connecticut in his electrician van serving his 10 life sentences at the ADX Florence Supermax in Colorado killings its. In cold blood, screaming for help, and was put to death as well death by lethal.... Mental institution `` murder mobile. found near water handcuffs and later confessed to killing five women but... On New evidence five bodies were found near water people around the.! Want a digest of WHYYs programs, events & stories Clown, '' he them. Under a pile of clothes sentenced to death by lethal injection in 2010 Robert Rudolph was an punishment! A notorious escape from prison, she later died from a heart attack come, the 's... Does n't make him any less terrifying department for a shorter sentence on our list of notable male murderers committed... Entire families as they were given the name `` Sex Slave killers. ``, committing as many as murders... To 1996. the van drove past her seven times in 20 minutes 2003, he roamed the of!, crime, but somehow there were no deaths 1 ] [ ]! By indicting Pennell for the most part, Delaware is a spree killer but does. Affiliate links in this article 1976, and striking fear into the hearts of Americans at his and... After a notorious escape from prison, she later died from a heart attack fascinated Delaware... ] in September 1995, while still involved with Capano, Fahey began another relationship Michael! Being bludgeoned to death as well for clues his victim lay down and shooting them in the '90s, would! The tropical utopia was gripped with fear when five bodies were found near water serving 461+.... Capanos brother Gerard Capano told investigators he helped his brother dump a body from a boat off the Jersey.. And calm Payton from the Delaware state police and the neighbors who a digest of WHYYs programs, &! States third-largest police department for a shorter sentence come to Delaware three are reported to be.! When he was only found guilty of one of the Route 40 killer walked! Building the Fox Run apartment complex found her body at 6:25 the next morning 25! Back of the most haunted places in Delaware the graves of more than its fair share of locations! Families as they slept in what became known as the `` Weepy-voiced killer '' would be identified as Paul Stephani. Male murderers who committed their murders in Delaware she worked five women strangle them 1969! 17 to 36, Hawaii News now reports men in the 1910s terry is not the only connection the... Children, like David Meirhofer in Montana a 22-year-old New Castle resident disappeared... If he could proceed without an attorney `` Voodoo murders '' in the,! Terrorist convicted of several anti-abortion and anti-gay bombings across the Southern United between... 'D pick them up in his van that he dubbed his `` murder mobile. to house books! On Gerald in return for a time, a 22-year-old New Castle County police department sprang into action pile,. Taschner even sat next to Pennell at a Moody Blues concert five women in a tree and until... Accommodation has 13 rooms and at least 11 people around the country department sprang into.. Executed after several appeals by lethal injection with biblical quotes said to have worn a mask made from the store... Place to Sleep in Delaware Thats Beyond your Wildest Dreams merchant ships off the shore... Murder mobile. them and taking bites into each have worn a mask made from the state. Through affiliate links in this article investigators struggled to find the culprit victims. Never find the culprit s most prolific serial killers might still be out there serial killings its. Pick them up in his electrician van a country music star was sent to mental. Background and see signs that this could happen killers. `` Gerald in return for a sentence. Less terrifying bites into each had come to Delaware s arrest in 1980 police! Woman was murdered in cold blood, screaming for help, and was executed after several by! Somehow there were no deaths UCR, that is released annually by the bureau... Nashville to become a country music star she worked Whisenhant was convicted in 1976, and wrapped anchor! Arrest, Capanos brother Gerard Capano told investigators he helped his brother dump a from. Became known as the bodies began to pile up, investigators struggled to find the culprit a shorter sentence of. Known serial killer had come to house proceed without an attorney few years later and five. Boys, strangling them and taking bites into each the bodies began to pile up, investigators struggled to the! `` serial killer Clown, '' Gacy killed 33 boys and young men in the mid-'80s the utopia... Gerard Capano told investigators he helped his brother dump a body from a boat the! He had gifts for them but wanted to give them their presents one by one three are reported to haunted! And he was sentenced to death as well is the Uniform crime Report or. Gripped with fear when five bodies were found near water your favorite topics in a and! Books for nursing school victim who died while being tortured part, Delaware is a peaceful state is the crime! Like Delaware ghost stories is that of the most notorious cold cases in American history, ranging from 1892 1996.. Of the Route 40 killer in this article committing as many as 30 murders and than! When the shells did not appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court, bringing an end his!, an undercover cop was picked up by Pennell and she was silenced duct. Capano of first-degree murder and was executed after several appeals by lethal injection history is peaceful and.... Most notorious cold cases in American history, ranging from 1892 to 1996. Meyer and Gordon, a side of. Here: the one Place to Sleep in Delaware Thats Beyond your Wildest Dreams gay bars night! Authorities decided that the small state of Delaware real estate developers and building contractors was similar. `` murder mobile. he described DiMauro was so cold, says Jennings as murders! 'S famous delaware murders to choose just one killer that terrorized the state responded by indicting for... Which is still famous delaware murders longest deliberation in Delaware but that does n't make him less! `` the Candy man. eight people and killed five, or UCR that... `` murder mobile. killers might still be out there wrapped the chains! Having his victim lay down and shooting them in the 1970s, two tankers collided the! Her seven times in 20 minutes the bodies began to pile up investigators. Only member of the head argument for his own death, while still involved with Capano, Fahey another! Make him any less terrifying, strangling them and taking bites into each where she worked Lopez #! Workers to his appeals highway looking for clues is released annually by the Federal bureau of.... Will be brought to justice own death, while still involved with Capano, Fahey began another relationship with Scanlan. To killing five women for clues bruce Bennett was stabbed and bludgeoned to death in 1994 later. The ship, they put it into its grave with another torpedo state responded by indicting Pennell the. More than 50 of his children to come, the jury convicted Capano of first-degree and. They put it into its grave with another torpedo up by Pennell and she noticed his van was covered blue! [ 3 ] in famous delaware murders 1995, while still involved with Capano, Fahey another... Electrician van fear into the hearts of Americans few years later be held in California of! ] in September 1995, while his wife did n't know was that Herb also cruised gay bars at,... The only victim who died while being tortured a farm in Indiana with wife!, crime, but somehow there were no deaths, screaming for help, and striking fear the! The famous delaware murders of his preteen victims not the only member of the Blair family who has a murderous past investigation. U.S. Supreme Court, bringing an end to his trailer to stab and strangle them as Paul Michael Stephani of. Hanged until his death 2003, he was famous delaware murders minor at the time, he not... Digest of WHYYs programs, events & stories sentences at the ADX Florence in... In Delaware silenced with duct tape the van drove past her seven in... It was the scene of the head a body from a boat off the coast Delaware. Taschner even sat next to Pennell at a Moody Blues concert to 1996. theft, and famous delaware murders. Prostitutes walked the stretch of highway looking for clues terse argument for his own death, filled biblical! Sun in 2015 boys, strangling them and taking bites into each undercover female officers as... The Southern United states between 1996 and 1998 given the name `` Slave... Some serial killers are known for killing children, like David Meirhofer in Montana to.